There is no evidence to suggest that American Idol and similar TV shows have ruined pop and rock music. In fact, these shows have provided a platform for talented musicians to showcase their skills to a wider audience. While there may be arguments that these shows focus on commercialization and mass appeal, they cannot be blamed for the quality or direction of contemporary pop and rock music.
It is important to note that popular music has always been influenced by market demand and commercial interests. The emergence of TV shows like American Idol simply reflects this reality. It is also worth acknowledging that these shows have helped to democratize the music industry by providing opportunities for individuals who may have been excluded from the traditional channels of music production and distribution.
Furthermore, it is difficult to make sweeping statements about the quality or direction of pop and rock music. While there may be examples of formulaic and uninspired music, there are also examples of innovative and meaningful work being produced by contemporary artists. It is up to individual listeners to make their own judgments about the value of different musical styles and genres.
Ultimately, the influence of American Idol and similar shows on pop and rock music is complex and multifaceted. While they have certainly had an impact on the industry, it is difficult to attribute any particular trend or development solely to these programs. It is important to consider a range of factors, including changes in technology, globalization, and cultural shifts, in order to fully understand the evolution of contemporary music.
Source:
Bennett, Andy. Popular Music and Youth Culture: Music, Identity and Place. Palgrave Macmillan, 2000.
