The evaluation of the status of movie soundtrack composers compared to great classical composers is a complex and subjective matter that cannot be easily measured. While both types of composers share a common trait of creating musical compositions, they operate in different genres with different historical contexts and artistic demands.
From a historical perspective, classical composers such as Bach, Beethoven, Mozart, and Wagner have established their reputation as some of the greatest composers in history. Their works have been performed and studied for centuries, influencing generations of musicians and listeners. Movie soundtrack composers, on the other hand, operate in a relatively new genre, with a history that dates back only a century.
Classical music is associated with Western art music, which is often characterized by its formal structure, complexity, and emotional depth. The genre has a rich history that has been shaped by the social and cultural context of different periods. In contrast, movie soundtracks are created to enhance the emotional impact of a film, and the music is often designed to support the storyline and mood of the movie.
In terms of artistic demands, classical composers are often expected to create works that showcase their technical mastery and creative vision. Their compositions are typically performed in a concert setting, with a focus on the musical score and the interpretation of the musicians. Movie soundtrack composers, however, are required to work within a collaborative setting, often with a director or producer, to create music that complements the visual and narrative aspects of the film.
It is worth noting that the distinction between classical and movie soundtrack composers is not absolute, as there have been instances where composers have bridged the gap between the two genres. For instance, composers such as John Williams and Hans Zimmer have composed music for both classical concerts and movie soundtracks. Their works have been well-received in both contexts, showcasing their versatility and creativity.
In conclusion, the comparison between movie soundtrack composers and great classical composers is a difficult one, as both genres operate in different contexts with different artistic demands. While classical composers have a long and established history, movie soundtrack composers have made significant contributions to the film industry, creating music that enhances the emotional impact of movies. It is up to the audience and critics to determine the value and significance of each composer's works, based on their respective contexts and artistic merits.