Screenwriting and filmmaking are creative arts that require a great deal of skill, talent, and training. While there are many resources available to aspiring writers and filmmakers, not all of these resources are equally helpful. In fact, some books can actually be quite unhelpful for screenwriters and filmmakers.
One type of book that is often criticized by screenwriters and filmmakers is the "how-to" guide. These books often prescribe a rigid formula for writing and filmmaking, which can stifle creativity and lead to formulaic, unoriginal work. They may also oversimplify the complex process of writing and filmmaking, leading aspiring writers and filmmakers astray.
Another type of unhelpful book is the one that focuses solely on theory and neglects practical application. These books may provide an interesting overview of the history and philosophy of screenwriting and filmmaking, but they do not provide practical advice on how to actually write a screenplay or make a film.
Some screenwriting and filmmaking books are also criticized for being outdated. The film and television industries are constantly evolving, and what worked in the past may no longer be relevant or effective today. Books that do not reflect these changes can be misleading for aspiring writers and filmmakers.
Finally, some screenwriting and filmmaking books are simply poorly written. They may be poorly structured, unclear, or contain errors. These books can be frustrating for readers and do not provide the comprehensive, reliable information that aspiring writers and filmmakers need.
In conclusion, not all books are equally helpful for screenwriters and filmmakers. "How-to" guides that prescribe a rigid formula, books that focus solely on theory, outdated books, and poorly written books are all examples of books that can be unhelpful for aspiring writers and filmmakers. It is important to seek out high-quality, reliable resources when learning about the craft of screenwriting and filmmaking.