Firstly, rock/pop music is generally simpler in structure and composition than classical orchestral music. It often uses a limited number of chords, a straightforward melody, and a repetitive structure. In contrast, classical orchestral music often involves complex harmonies, intricate counterpoint, and challenging instrumentation. The complexity of classical music can make it more challenging to compose, especially for those without a formal musical education or training.
Secondly, there is a significant cultural divide between popular music and classical music. Popular music is more accessible and widely understood by the general public. Rock and pop songs often have lyrics that convey a clear message or emotion, making them more relatable to a broader audience. In contrast, classical music often lacks lyrics and relies on musical expression and interpretation, which can be more challenging to comprehend for non-musicians.
Thirdly, the tools and resources available for creating rock/pop music are more accessible than those for creating classical orchestral music. With the advent of digital audio workstations and software instruments, creating rock/pop music has become more accessible to the masses. The cost of creating high-quality music has decreased significantly, making it easier for aspiring musicians to get started. In contrast, classical orchestral music requires access to expensive instruments, trained musicians, and dedicated recording facilities, making it much more challenging to create on a budget.
Finally, the differences in education and training required for writing rock/pop music versus classical orchestral music play a significant role. While many rock/pop musicians may have learned their craft through self-study or informal training, classical composers typically undergo years of formal training and education. They must learn the intricacies of music theory, orchestration, and composition, which can be daunting for those without a musical background.
In conclusion, there are several reasons why so many people can write rock/pop music but not classical style orchestral music. These reasons include the simplicity of rock/pop music, the cultural divide between popular and classical music, the accessibility of music creation tools and resources, and the differences in education and training required for each genre. Understanding these factors can help aspiring musicians determine which path to pursue and how to develop their skills in their chosen genre. Sources consulted for this article include The New Yorker and The Guardian.